رهپویه معماری و شهرسازی

رهپویه معماری و شهرسازی

طراحی و تبیین الگوی مدیریت ریسک جهت حفاظت پایدار از میراث جهانی قنات قصبه گناباد

نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی

نویسندگان
1 مرکز پژوهشی جندی شاپور، دانشگاه صنعتی جندی شاپور دزفول، ایران
2 1-مرکز پژوهشی جندی شاپور، دانشگاه صنعتی جندی شاپور دزفول، ایران 2-دانشکده معماری و ‌شهرسازی، دانشگاه علم و صنعت، تهران، ایران
چکیده
قنات قصبۀ گناباد به عنوان اثر ثبت‎شده در فهرست میراث جهانی یونسکو، در سال‎های اخیر با مجموعه‎ای از مخاطرات محیطی، مدیریتی، اجتماعی و فنی مواجه بوده که پایداری و تداوم عملکرد آن را تهدید می‎کنند. هدف پژوهش حاضر، شناسایی ریسک‎های مؤثر بر این میراث آبی و تدوین چارچوبی برای مدیریت ریسک در راستای حفاظت پایدار آن است. در این مطالعه کاربردی و توصیفی ـ تحلیلی، ابتدا عوامل داخلی و خارجی مؤثر بر مدیریت قنات از طریق SWOT شناسایی و دسته‎بندی شدند. سپس با بهره‎گیری از فرایند تحلیل سلسله‎مراتبی (AHP)، معیارها، زیرمعیارها و راهکارهای مدیریتی اولویت‎بندی گردیدند. داده‎های پژوهش از طریق بررسی اسناد، مطالعات میدانی و نظرات گروه پازده‎نفره از خبرگان حوزه‎های میراث فرهنگی، مدیریت ریسک، منابع آب و قنات گردآوری شد. برای تجمیع قضاوت‎های خبرگان از میانگین هندسی استفاده شد و ماتریس‎های مقایسات زوجی دارای نسبت سازگاری کمتر از 0.1 بودند. یافته‎ها نشان داد که چالش‎های محیطی و بیرونی (نظیر خشکسالی، افت آب‎های زیرزمینی و فشارهای توسعه‎ای) بالاترین اولویت را در تهدید پایداری قنات دارند. همچنین نتایج تحلیل حساسیت نیز پایداری رتبه‎بندی و استحکام نتایج مدل تصمیم‎گیری را در سناریوهای مختلف وزنی تأیید می‎کند. بر اساس نتایج، مجموعه‎ای از اقدامات کوتاه‎مدت، میان‎مدت و بلندمدت در قالب یک ماتریس اجرایی شامل نهادهای مسئول، اولویت اجرا و شاخص‎های پایش پیشنهاد شد. پژوهش حاضر نشان می‎دهد که تلفیق استاندارد با روش SWOT-AHP می‎تواند چارچوبی کارآمد برای مدیریت ریسک و حفاظت پایدار میراث آبی تاریخی فراهم آورد و به عنوان الگویی قابل‎تعمیم برای سایر سامانه‎های قناتی و میراث آبی مشابه مورد استفاده قرار گیرد.
کلیدواژه‌ها
موضوعات

عنوان مقاله English

Design and Development of a Risk Management Model for the Sustainable Conservation of the Qasabeh Qanat of Gonabad World Heritage Site

نویسندگان English

Mehdi Pirhayati 1
Behnaz Safar Ali Najar 1
Amir Tayyebi 1
Hossein Raie 2
1 Jundi-Shapur Research Institute, Jundi-Shapur University of Technology, Dezful, Iran
2 1-Jundi-Shapur Research Institute, Jundi-Shapur University of Technology, Dezful, Iran 2-Assistant Professor, Faculty of Architecture and Urban Planning, Iran University of Science and Technology, Tehran, Iran
چکیده English

The Qasabeh Qanat of Gonabad, recognized as one of the most remarkable examples of ancient hydraulic engineering and inscribed on the UNESCO World Heritage List, represents a unique socio-hydrological heritage system that has functioned continuously for centuries in the arid landscapes of northeastern Iran. As one of the oldest and deepest qanat systems in the world, it demonstrates an extraordinary human capacity to adapt to harsh environmental conditions through sustainable water management practices. The Qasabeh Qanat is considered a “living heritage system,” whose survival depends not only on the preservation of its physical structure but also on the continuity of traditional knowledge, effective governance mechanisms, and the ecological balance of the aquifer that sustains it. However, in recent decades, this historic infrastructure has faced increasingly complex and interconnected challenges resulting from environmental change, socio-economic transformation, and evolving management structures. Climate change, prolonged droughts, unsustainable groundwater extraction, demographic shifts, and weakening traditional maintenance systems have collectively intensified pressures on the qanat’s integrity and functionality. Despite its global significance, there remains a critical lack of a comprehensive and systematic risk management framework tailored specifically to socio-hydrological heritage systems such as qanats. Addressing this gap, the present study develops an integrated risk management framework for the Qasabeh Qanat of Gonabad aimed at identifying, classifying, and prioritizing the major risks threatening its Outstanding Universal Value (OUV) while proposing a structured and time-bound strategy for its long-term conservation and sustainable management.
This study is applied in terms of its objective and descriptive-analytical in its methodological approach. The research adopts a hybrid methodological framework grounded in the principles of the ISO 31000 international standard for risk management. This framework provides a systematic and continuous process for identifying, assessing, mitigating, and monitoring risks. The study began by establishing the contextual framework, which included defining the internal and external conditions affecting the qanat system, identifying relevant stakeholders, and clarifying management objectives related to heritage conservation and water resource sustainability. Following this stage, a systematic risk identification process was conducted using the Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats (SWOT) analytical framework. This qualitative analysis drew upon historical management records, previous conservation initiatives, technical reports, and extensive field studies. The SWOT analysis enabled the identification of a wide spectrum of internal factors—including structural conditions of the underground tunnels, traditional maintenance practices, governance arrangements, and socio-cultural dynamics—as well as external pressures such as environmental hazards, economic constraints, and policy challenges. Through this rigorous process, a comprehensive inventory of potential risks was developed, encompassing both endogenous vulnerabilities (e.g., an aging demographic of skilled traditional workers, fragmented land ownership, insufficient financial resources) and exogenous drivers (e.g., climate change, groundwater depletion, urban expansion, and agricultural intensification).
To move beyond qualitative identification and establish a robust, quantitative basis for decision-making, the study employed the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) to evaluate and prioritize the identified risks and corresponding management strategies. Empirical data was gathered through the judgments of a specialized panel consisting of 15 experts representing multiple disciplinary backgrounds, including cultural heritage conservation, risk management, hydrogeology, water engineering, and local governance. To synthesize and aggregate the individual judgments of the expert panel, the geometric mean method was utilized. The analysis was conducted using Expert Choice 11 software, yielding a Consistency Ratio (CR) of less than 0.1 across all pairwise comparison matrices, validating the reliability and coherence of the expert judgments.
The decision hierarchy was structured into four main criteria categories: managerial and institutional challenges (MC1), technical and physical challenges (MC2), socio-economic and cultural challenges (MC3), and environmental and external threats (MC4). The AHP evaluation revealed a distinct hierarchy among the identified risks, highlighting the overwhelming predominance of environmental and external pressures. Environmental and external threats emerged as the most critical category (weight: 0.410), empirically demonstrating that the most significant threats to the qanat’s sustainability originate from macro-level processes largely beyond the immediate control of site managers. Within this dominant category, climate change and prolonged drought conditions were identified as the single most critical risk factor across the entire system (weight: 0.519). This specific risk functions as a fundamental driver that intrinsically intensifies cascading vulnerabilities within the heritage system, leading to measurable reductions in water discharge levels.
The second most influential category consisted of managerial and institutional challenges (weight: 0.301), underscoring the importance of resilient governance structures. Within this category, insufficient and unstable funding for conservation activities emerged as the most significant sub-criterion (weight: 0.484), indicating that without reliable financial resources, systematic maintenance and protective infrastructure investments become structurally impossible. Technical and physical challenges ranked third (weight: 0.171), encompassing structural degradation and potential physical damage, with sediment accumulation identified as the most critical technical issue (weight: 0.402) due to its direct impact on hydrodynamic efficiency. Finally, socio-economic and cultural challenges ranked fourth (weight: 0.118). Despite its lower relative weight, this remains an essential qualitative dimension. The erosion of indigenous knowledge and traditional maintenance skills due to an aging workforce emerged as the most prominent risk here (weight: 0.431). The systemic analysis suggests that technical and socio-cultural challenges function primarily as intermediary risks catalyzed by broader environmental and managerial pressures; for example, drought-induced water reduction lowers economic motivation for maintenance, which subsequently accelerates sediment accumulation and the abandonment of traditional practices.
To validate these findings, a rigorous sensitivity analysis was performed to test the stability and robustness of the prioritization results. The sensitivity analysis confirmed that the structural ranking remained stable across various weighted scenarios. Specifically, the analysis demonstrated that even dynamic variations in the weight assigned to the environmental criterion maintained the overarching necessity of the proposed risk treatment strategies, thereby highlighting the dominant and pervasive influence of environmental conditions on the socio-hydrological system. The moderate changes simulated in the weights of other criteria produced relatively negligible impacts on the final strategic prioritization. This quantitative confirmation reinforces the definitive conclusion that external environmental processes—particularly climate-induced water scarcity—represent the critical drivers shaping the future trajectory of the Qasabeh Qanat.
Based on the synthesis of these findings, the study developed and proposed a comprehensive, time-bound risk treatment plan meticulously aligned with the continuous improvement cycle of the ISO 31000 standard. The proposed strategic response is structured across three distinct temporal horizons: short-term (within two years), medium-term (within five years), and long-term (within ten years), formalized within an executive matrix that specifies responsible institutions, implementation priorities, and precise monitoring indicators. Short-term measures focus primarily on immediate preventive actions and the establishment of a robust, data-driven information base for future decision-making. These critical actions include updating baseline documentation of the qanat’s physical condition, developing high-resolution GIS-based hazard maps addressing acute risks such as flash floods, earthquakes, and water pollution, establishing a dedicated multi-source financial fund for urgent conservation activities, and formalizing emergency response protocols among relevant local and national institutions.
Medium-term strategies emphasize the strengthening of routine management practices and the deployment of protective infrastructure. These measures incorporate periodic updates of structural risk assessments, the engineering reinforcement of highly vulnerable underground segments, the installation of advanced continuous water-monitoring telemetry systems, and the institutional revitalization of traditional maintenance practices, specifically the systematic dredging of sediment. Long-term strategies focus on achieving systemic resilience and adaptive management. These overarching goals include the preparation and legislative approval of a comprehensive master plan for structural stabilization, the strict integration of the qanat’s protective buffer zones into regional macro-level land-use and urban development plans, and the strategic promotion of sustainable cultural tourism. Furthermore, long-term educational initiatives aimed at formally preserving, documenting, and transmitting the indigenous engineering knowledge of the moqannis are strongly recommended. Ultimately, the present research demonstrates that the methodological integration of the ISO 31000 standard with the SWOT-AHP analytical framework provides a highly effective, scientifically rigorous model for managing risk and ensuring the sustainable conservation of historical water heritage. This integrated framework not only addresses the specific vulnerabilities of the Qasabeh Qanat of Gonabad but also serves as a robust, generalizable paradigm that can be successfully adapted and applied to other qanat systems and similar socio-hydrological heritage sites globally.

This study is applied in terms of its objective and descriptive-analytical in its methodological approach. The research adopts a hybrid methodological framework grounded in the principles of the ISO 31000 international standard for risk management. This framework provides a systematic and continuous process for identifying, assessing, mitigating, and monitoring risks. The study began with establishing the contextual framework, which included defining the internal and external conditions affecting the qanat system, identifying relevant stakeholders, and clarifying management objectives related to heritage conservation and water resource sustainability. Following this stage, a systematic risk identification process was conducted using the Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats (SWOT) analytical framework. This qualitative analysis drew upon historical management records, previous conservation initiatives, technical reports, and extensive field studies. The SWOT analysis enabled the identification of a wide spectrum of internal factors—including structural conditions of the underground tunnels, traditional maintenance practices, governance arrangements, and socio-cultural dynamics—as well as external pressures such as environmental hazards, economic constraints, and policy challenges. Through this rigorous process, a comprehensive inventory of potential risks was developed, encompassing both endogenous vulnerabilities (e.g., an aging demographic of skilled traditional workers, fragmented land ownership, insufficient financial resources) and exogenous drivers (e.g., climate change, groundwater depletion, urban expansion, and agricultural intensification).
To move beyond qualitative identification and establish a robust, quantitative basis for decision-making, the study employed the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) to evaluate and prioritize the identified risks and corresponding management strategies. Empirical data was gathered through the judgments of a specialized panel consisting of 15 experts representing multiple disciplinary backgrounds, including cultural heritage conservation, risk management, hydrogeology, water engineering, and local governance. To synthesize and aggregate the individual judgments of the expert panel, the geometric mean method was utilized. The analysis was conducted using Expert Choice 11 software, yielding a Consistency Ratio (CR) of less than 0.1 across all pairwise comparison matrices, validating the reliability and coherence of the expert judgments.
The decision hierarchy was structured into four main criteria categories: managerial and institutional challenges (MC1), technical and physical challenges (MC2), socio-economic and cultural challenges (MC3), and environmental and external threats (MC4). The AHP evaluation revealed a distinct hierarchy among the identified risks, highlighting the overwhelming predominance of environmental and external pressures. Environmental and external threats emerged as the most critical category (weight: 0.410), empirically demonstrating that the most significant threats to the qanat’s sustainability originate from macro-level processes largely beyond the immediate control of site managers. Within this dominant category, climate change and prolonged drought conditions were identified as the single most critical risk factor across the entire system (weight: 0.519). This specific risk functions as a fundamental driver that intrinsically intensifies cascading vulnerabilities within the heritage system, leading to measurable reductions in water discharge levels.
The second most influential category consisted of managerial and institutional challenges (weight: 0.301), underscoring the importance of resilient governance structures. Within this category, insufficient and unstable funding for conservation activities emerged as the most significant sub-criterion (weight: 0.484), indicating that without reliable financial resources, systematic maintenance and protective infrastructure investments become structurally impossible. Technical and physical challenges ranked third (weight: 0.171), encompassing structural degradation and potential physical damage, with sediment accumulation identified as the most critical technical issue (weight: 0.402) due to its direct impact on hydrodynamic efficiency. Finally, socio-economic and cultural challenges ranked fourth (weight: 0.118). Despite its lower relative weight, this remains an essential qualitative dimension. The erosion of indigenous knowledge and traditional maintenance skills due to an aging workforce emerged as the most prominent risk here (weight: 0.431). The systemic analysis suggests that technical and socio-cultural challenges function primarily as intermediary risks catalyzed by broader environmental and managerial pressures; for example, drought-induced water reduction lowers economic motivation for maintenance, which subsequently accelerates sediment accumulation and the abandonment of traditional practices.
To validate these findings, a rigorous sensitivity analysis was performed to test the stability and robustness of the prioritization results. The sensitivity analysis confirmed that the structural ranking remained stable across various weighted scenarios. Specifically, the analysis demonstrated that even dynamic variations in the weight assigned to the environmental criterion maintained the overarching necessity of the proposed risk treatment strategies, thereby highlighting the dominant and pervasive influence of environmental conditions on the socio-hydrological system. The moderate changes simulated in the weights of other criteria produced relatively negligible impacts on the final strategic prioritization. This quantitative confirmation reinforces the definitive conclusion that external environmental processes—particularly climate-induced water scarcity—represent the absolute critical drivers shaping the future trajectory of the Qasabeh Qanat.
Based on the synthesis of these findings, the study developed and proposed a comprehensive, time-bound risk treatment plan meticulously aligned with the continuous improvement cycle of the ISO 31000 standard. The proposed strategic response is structured across three distinct temporal horizons: short-term (within two years), medium-term (within five years), and long-term (within ten years), formalized within an executive matrix that specifies responsible institutions, implementation priorities, and precise monitoring indicators. Short-term measures focus primarily on immediate preventive actions and the establishment of a robust, data-driven information base for future decision-making. These critical actions include updating baseline documentation of the qanat’s physical condition, developing high-resolution GIS-based hazard maps addressing acute risks such as flash floods, earthquakes, and water pollution, establishing a dedicated multi-source financial fund for urgent conservation activities, and formalizing emergency response protocols among relevant local and national institutions.
Medium-term strategies emphasize the strengthening of routine management practices and the deployment of protective infrastructure. These measures incorporate periodic updates of structural risk assessments, the engineering reinforcement of highly vulnerable underground segments, the installation of advanced continuous water monitoring telemetry, and the institutional revitalization of traditional maintenance practices, specifically the systematic dredging of sediment. Long-term strategies focus on achieving systemic resilience and adaptive management. These overarching goals include the preparation and legislative approval of a comprehensive master plan for structural stabilization, the strict integration of the qanat’s protective buffer zones into regional macro-level land-use and urban development plans, and the strategic promotion of sustainable cultural tourism. Furthermore, long-term educational initiatives aimed at formally preserving, documenting, and transmitting the indigenous engineering knowledge of the moqannis are strongly recommended. Ultimately, the present research demonstrates that the methodological integration of the ISO 31000 standard with the SWOT-AHP analytical framework provides a highly effective, scientifically rigorous model for managing risk and ensuring the sustainable conservation of historical water heritage. This integrated framework not only addresses the specific vulnerabilities of the Qasabeh Qanat of Gonabad but also serves as a robust, generalizable paradigm that can be successfully adapted and applied to other qanat systems and similar socio-hydrological heritage sites globally.

کلیدواژه‌ها English

World Heritage
Water Heritage
Qasabeh Qanat of Gonabad
Risk Management
ISO 31000
SWOT-AHP
حسینی، سید حسین؛ جهان‎دیده، زهیر (1395)، چالش‎های حمایت‎های کیفری از قنوات. مطالعۀ موردی: قنات قصبۀ گناباد، مطالعات حقوق انرژی، دوره 2 پاییز و زمستان 1396 شماره 2، 279 – 304.
شیخی، داود؛ پازکی، معصومه (1400)، بررسی کارکردهای اجتماعی قنات در نواحی روستایی با تأکید بر شاخص‎های سرمایه اجتماعی (مورد مطالعه: شهرستان همدان)، پژوهش‎های جغرافیای اقتصادی، 2(3)، 59-73.
فداکارداورانی، محمدمهدی (1388)، قنات و سرمایه اجتماعی، برنامه‎ریزی رفاه و توسعه اجتماعی، 1(1)، 149-179.
مالیان، عباس؛ تیموری دامسکی، مرضیه؛ عربی، مهدی (1396)، آشکارسازی و مستندنگاری رشته قنات برپایه ادغام تصاویر هوایی و فضایی، نشریه علوم و فنون نقشه برداری، 7(2)، 79-92.
مختارنیا، کاظم؛ طالبیان، محمدحسن؛ عشرتی، پرستو (1401)، توسعۀ چهارچوب نظری ارزش در قنات ایرانی، مطالعات معماری ایران، 11 (21)، 205-223.
گزارش پایگاه میراث جهانی قنات ایرانی (1401).
 
Arrighi, Ch., A global scale analysis of river flood risk of UNESCO world heritage sites, Frontiers in Water 3 (2021) 1–12, https://doi.org/10.3389/frwa.2021.764459.
Attarian, K., Safar Ali Najar, B. Heritage documentation and structural analysis of historic water-supply canals. Environ Earth Sci 81, 100 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12665-022-10206-1
Bosher, L., Kim, D., Okubo, T., Chmutina, K, J., (2019). Dealing with multiple hazards and threats on cultural heritage sites: an assessment of 80 case studies, Disaster Prev. Manag. : Int. J. 29 (1). 109–128, https://doi.org/10.1108/dpm-08-2018-0245.
Boumaiza, A.; Sajjad, M.; Sanfilippo, A.; Mohandes, N. (2022). Energy trading blockchain framework, agents modelling approach. In Sustainable Energy-Water-Environment Nexus in Deserts: Proceedings of the First International Conference on Sustainable Energy-Water-Environment Nexus in Desert Climates; Springer International Publishing: Cham, Switzerland, 2022; pp. 543–550. https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-030-76081-6_68.
Brimblecombe, P. (2014). Refining climate change threats to heritage, J. Inst. Conserv. 37 (2) 85–93, https://doi.org/10.1080/19455224.2014.916226.
Carmichael, B., Cathy Daly, Sandra Fatori′c, Mark Macklin, Sue McIntyre-Tamwoy, Witiya Pittungnapoo, Global riverine archaeology and cultural heritage: flood-risk management and Adaptation for the anthropogenic climate change crisis, Climate 11 (2023) 1–12, https://doi.org/10.3390/cli11100197.
Casarotto, A., Fiorentino, S., & Vandini, M. (2025). An Approach to Risk Assessment and Planned Preventive Maintenance of Cultural Heritage: The Case of the Hypogeum Archaeological Site of Sigismund Street (Rimini, Italy). Heritage, 8(9), 344. https://doi.org/10.3390/heritage8090344
Durrant, L. J., Vadher, N., A., Teller, Jigyasu, R. (2023). Disaster risk management and cultural heritage: The perceptions of European world heritage site managers on disaster risk management, International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, Volume 89, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijdrr.2023.103625.
Esmaeili, G.; Habibi, A.; Esmaeili, H. R. Qanat system, an ancient water management system in Iran: History, architectural design and fish diversity. Int. J. Aquat. Biol. 2022, 10, 131–144.
Ghasemi H, Valipour E, Morad DH (2013) Application of traditional architectural structure as a sustainable approach to the mitigation of shortage water supply in desert regions. Acad J Sci 2(1): 125–132
Guzman, P. (2025). Cultural heritage in climate planning: An analysis of the Norwegian national climate documents and guidelines, Journal of Cultural Heritage, Volume 74, 35-47, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.culher.2025.05.003.
Guzman, P., Fatori′c, S., Ishizawa, M., Monitoring climate change in world heritage properties: evaluating landscape-based approach in the state of conservation system, Climate 8 (39) (2020) 1–19, https://doi.org/10.3390/cli8030039.
Harandi MF, de Vries MJ (2014) An appraisal of the qualifying role of hydraulic heritage systems: a case study of qanats in central Iran. Water Sci Technol: Water Supply 14(6): 1124–1132
HP of UNESCO World Heritage Centre: The Operational Guidelines for the Implementation of the World Heritage Convention. (accessed July/18.2023).
ICCROM (2016) A Guide to Risk Management of Cultural Heritage, Government of Canada, Canadian Conservation Institute. ICCROM-ATHAR Regional Conservation Centre, Sharjah, U. A. E. www.iccrom.org/athar
ISO 31000, (2009). provides principles and generic guidelines on risk management. https://www.iso.org/standard/43170.html
Li, M. (2024), Disaster risk management of cultural heritage: A global scale analysis of characteristics, multiple hazards, lessons learned from historical disasters, and issues in current DRR measures in world heritage sites, International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, Volume 110, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijdrr.2024.104633.
Mohtashami, A., Al-Ghafri, A., Labbaf Khaneiki, M. Akbarpour, A., (2025). Application of the quality border delineation for sustainable protection of groundwater resources, qanats, against contamination using meshless numerical method, Journal of Contaminant Hydrology, Volume 273, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jconhyd.2025.104608.
Mousazadeh H, Ghorbani A, Azadi H, Almani FA, Zangiabadi A, Zhu K, Dávid LD. (2023). Developing Sustainable Behaviours for Underground Heritage Tourism Management: The Case of Persian Qanats, a UNESCO World Heritage Property. Land. 12(4): 808. https://doi.org/10.3390/land12040808
Naeimiasl F, Vahidi H, Soheili N. (2025). Leveraging Principal Component Analysis for Data-Driven and Objective Weight Assignment in Spatial Decision-Making Framework for Qanat-Induced Subsidence Susceptibility Assessment in Railway Networks. ISPRS International Journal of Geo-Information. 14(5): 195. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijgi14050195
Salek, A. Rediscovering Community Participation in Persian Qanats: An Actor-Network Framework. Eur. J. Creat. Pract. Cities Landsc. 2019, 2, 153–172.
Wang, T., Fu, Zh., Zhang, Sh., Li, Zh., (2025). Water erosion risk assessment and predictive modelling for cultural heritage under climate change: A case study of the Great Wall in the Yellow River Basin, China, Journal of Cleaner Production, Volume 510, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2025.145645.
Wang, X., Griffiths, J., Gibson, A., Kumar, P., (2025). Disaster management practices in churches in London, UK, International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, Volume 128, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijdrr.2025.105690.
Wei, G., Han, G., Lang, X., (2024). Using RS and GIS for risk management of natural disasters consequences: The case of cultural heritage in Jinan city, China, Heliyon, Volume 10, Issue 19, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2024.e38217.
Yousefian, N., Shahnoushi Foroushani, N., Firozzare, A., Taghvaeian, S., (2025). Prioritising the effects of sustainable development of reviving the qanat in Fariman-Torbat Jam plain- The Eastern of Iran, Groundwater for Sustainable Development, Volume 28, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gsd.2024.101365.
 

  • تاریخ دریافت 30 فروردین 1405
  • تاریخ بازنگری 01 مرداد 1405
  • تاریخ پذیرش 02 مرداد 1405